A World of Tunings · Comparison
The same arpeggio and melody in four tunings in turn: Pythagorean, just, meantone, equal temperament; three rounds. The blind test is in the panel: just or equal? There is no claim of any effect.
When and how to listen
This session sets four tuning systems side by side and invites you to compare them by ear. The same arpeggio and the same short melody play in four tunings in turn: Pythagorean, just intonation, meantone and equal temperament. Each tuning lasts about twenty seconds and the four-tuning round comes three times; you can take the first round without knowing what to listen for, and focus on a particular note in the later ones.
Give most of your attention to E and A: across the four tunings C stays in place, while those two move the most, with about 21.5 cents between just intonation and Pythagorean. Try to separate the bright Pythagorean third, the soft just third and the slightly wide equal-tempered third. Which tuning sounds familiar to you may depend on your own listening habits.
It lasts five minutes and needs no headphones; there is no drone in this part, only synthesised notes and a quiet brown noise. After listening you can open the blind test in the panel: in the question Just or equal?, half of the samples are in just intonation and half in equal temperament; over 16 trials chance gives about 8 correct, and the criterion is 12. The result is kept in the Experiment notebook, on this device only.
Liner notes
- Bed
- Brown noise
- Body
- Tonal voice
- What do you hear?
- Warm · slowly evolving · melodic
Sound recipe and timeline
How is this sound made?
- Brown noise−30 dB
- Tonal voice−18 dB
Tonal voice · 300 notes
- Reverb: room, 10% mix
In the room you can listen to each layer on its own, change its settings and save it as your own recipe.
Sound is generated on this device in real time; no files are downloaded from a server. There is a 2 s fade-in at the start and a 4 s fade-out at the end.
Compare with another sound
Open comparison
What do we know, what don't we know?
S · Soundscape, no claim
No health or mental-effect claim at all; it is simply a soundscape.
This session isn't linked to any claim of effect.
Similar sounds
The five sounds closest to this one by measured sound features.
- 1Auditory Memory · Recognition by RepetitionWarm · slowly evolving · melodic
- 2A World of Tunings · PythagorasWarm · slowly evolving · melodic
- 3A World of Tunings · Equal TemperamentWarm · slowly evolving · melodic
- 4Auditory Memory · The Same Melody?Warm · slowly evolving · melodic
- 5Auditory Memory · Melodic ContourWarm · slowly evolving · melodic
Keep your device volume comfortable, preferably below 60%. You can also use your device's headphone-safety settings.