Evidence methodology
Today 35 claims and 204 sources are shown; 2 claims are kept out of the product and shown nowhere. All were assessed with the rules below.
Scale
The level is shown with a letter, a shape and text, never with colour alone. "It doesn't work" and "the evidence is not yet sufficient" are different things; the cards use the latter.
- Strong evidence
- Several high-quality systematic reviews or randomised trials with consistent results.
- Moderate evidence
- A few controlled studies or meta-analyses; reasonable but limited generalisability.
- Preliminary/mixed evidence
- Small trials or pilot studies; inconsistent results.
- Insufficient evidence
- No clinical support; only laboratory findings, anecdotes or a single small study.
- Traditional/spiritual practice
- No scientific claim is made; it is offered as a cultural or personal practice.
- Soundscape, no claim
- No health or mental-effect claim at all; it is simply a soundscape.
The pattern of an evidence sentence
The letter, the shape and the sentence should say the same thing: the stronger the evidence, the firmer the verb; the weaker, the more cautious. We write evidence sentences with this pattern; existing wordings are being reviewed against it.
| Level | Certainty (close to GRADE) | Sentence pattern |
|---|---|---|
| A · Strong evidence | High | [X] reduces [Y].[X] results in little to no difference in [Y]. |
| B · Moderate evidence | Medium | [X] probably reduces [Y]. |
| C · Preliminary/mixed evidence | Low | [X] may reduce [Y].The evidence suggests [X] reduces [Y]. |
| D · Insufficient evidence | Very low | The evidence is very uncertain about the effect of [X] on [Y]. (No direction is stated.) |
| T · Traditional/spiritual practice | No scientific certainty is assigned | Fixed sentence: a traditional or spiritual practice, not a scientific claim. |
| Soundscape, no claim | No claim | Fixed sentence: no health or mental-effect claim at all; it is simply a soundscape. |
"No evidence of an effect" is not the same as "evidence of no effect"; the sentence is rewritten in the opposite direction to test it. The first sentence of "What don't we know?" says in plain words why we are not sure: the studies were small, the results varied, or the studies did not cover the people we are interested in.
The pattern is adapted from the GRADE Working Group's guidance on informative statements and from chapter 15 of the Cochrane Handbook: Santesso N, Glenton C, Dahm P et al. GRADE guidelines 26. J Clin Epidemiol. 2020;119:126-135. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2019.10.014
Schünemann HJ, Vist GE, Higgins JPT et al. Interpreting results and drawing conclusions. In: Higgins JPT, Thomas J, Chandler J et al. (eds.) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Wiley; 2019:403-431. doi:10.1002/9781119536604.ch15
Reading the lens
Each claim is a tree: the claim, two branches beneath it (what we know, what we don't know) and the findings on the branches. The findings are the sentences of the claim's two paragraphs; each sentence is tied to the source it describes and to its kind.
- Support
- The sentence points the same way as the claim; the source it describes is named beside it.
- Limit
- The sentence narrows the claim's scope or reports a contrary result.
- Evidence gap
- A question that has not been studied or settled; shown with a dashed edge.
- Context
- A definition, history or scope note; it does not point the way of the claim and carries no label.
We show no counts or percentages: how many studies support something is not the strength of the evidence (vote counting). Weight is conveyed in words and by study design. On the evidence map, too, more claims in a cell does not mean stronger evidence.
Rules
- A session is never shown as stronger than the weakest scientific claim it relies on, and the claim's technique (e.g. binaural beats) must actually be present in the session.
- Every source's citation, DOI or PMID is checked one by one against its Crossref or PubMed record. Fields that cannot be found are left empty; no number or citation is guessed.
- A retracted publication is never used as evidence; such publications are listed separately in the library.
- Every claim has a version and a changelog, and every claim is reviewed again at least every six months.
- Traditional and spiritual practices (✦ T) are never presented as scientific claims. Dangerous or legally risky claims are never included in the product.
- Every interface and marketing text passes an automated language check: promises of diagnosis, treatment or recovery, and benefit claims tied to disease names, cannot be published.
AI and review
Editorial responsibility: Murat Tunalı · Frekans Studio. Editorial responsibility does not mean independent scientific review; draft cards await human review and are not used in recommendations.
The first drafts of the claim texts were prepared by an AI model (Claude). Before publication, every source's citation was re-verified against primary records (Crossref, PubMed/Europe PMC, ClinicalTrials.gov), the figures were checked against the studies' abstracts and open-access full texts, and the errors found were corrected. Publication was approved by Frekans Studio. No independent scientific adviser has reviewed it yet. Each card shows the last and next review dates.
Conflicts of interest
Frekans Studio has no commercial relationship with any manufacturer, device company or research group.
Editorial and corrections policy
Responsibility. Murat Tunalı (Frekans Studio) is responsible for publishing every text on the site; no scientific title is claimed. First drafts of claim and guide texts are prepared by an AI model; before publication the citations are verified against primary records, the numbers are compared with the studies' abstracts and the claim linter scans for prohibited wording. No independent scientific adviser has reviewed the site yet; when a review takes place, the reviewer's name, title and institution appear on the page and in the structured data, and never before.
Versions and dates. Every claim has a version number, a last-review and a next-review date; when the evidence data changes the version goes up and a line is added to the claim's changelog. Guide articles show their first publication and last update dates. A retracted publication is never linked as evidence; if a retraction is learned of later, the source is removed and the claim's level is reassessed.
Corrections. A reported error (a wrong citation, a wrong number, a sentence the source does not support) is examined within 30 days. A confirmed error is corrected in the source and claim data, the claim's version goes up and the change is logged with its reason; until it is corrected, the wrong sentence is removed. Corrections are not silent: what changed and why stays in the log. Report address: frekans@frekans.studio.
Independence. There are no ads, sponsors, affiliate links or paid content; since no user data is collected, correction and publishing decisions rest on sources, not on reader metrics. Claims in the Myths section are never built into the product and are shown only with the verdict that they are unsupported.