02 / Explore · Claim05 / Menu · Claim

ClaimVersion 3 ·

The makam tradition and moods

T · Traditional/spiritual practice A makam is a melodic system of Turkish music; its effect on mood is a historical account, not a scientific claim.

Summary

What don't we know? These mappings are historical accounts: with no research showing their validity and reliability, they have no clinical value today.

Claim reviewed: The Ottoman music tradition held that makams affect the mind and mood.

On the map · Music and sound × Culture and traditionMakam

No scientific claim is made; it is offered as a cultural or personal practice.

A traditional or spiritual practice, not a scientific claim.

What do we know, what don't we know?

What do we know?

  • Safi al-Din al-Urmawi's twelve modes were matched to the zodiac signs and his four branches to the four elements.Özkan 2003
  • SupportOttoman physicians such as Şuuri Hasan Efendi and Gevrekzade Hasan Efendi wrote about the effects of makams on emotions.Çoban 2012
  • At the Bayezid II Darüşşifa in Edirne, music is mentioned as an experimental practice alongside the traditional medicine of the period.Kıranlar & Koçak 2017

What don't we know?

  • LimitThese mappings are historical accounts: with no research showing their validity and reliability, they have no clinical value today.Çoban 2012
  • Evidence gapNo specific effect of listening to a makam has been shown scientifically.

Each finding links to its source. Consider supporting results, limitations and open questions together. Reading the lens

Sources (3)

  1. Hoş sedanın gücü: Müzikoterapi

    Review · 2012

    The author, a psychiatrist and performer of classical Turkish music, reports that the link between makam and body is said to go back to al-Farabi and that Ottoman physicians such as Şuuri Hasan Efendi and Gevrekzade Hasan Efendi wrote about the effects of makams on emotions. In his view this remains historical information: with no research showing its validity and reliability, it has no clinical value today.

    A magazine article, not peer-reviewed research (Spring 2012). It contains other views on music that are not used here; only the section on the historical nature of the makam tradition (p. 69) is relied on.

    Çoban A. Hoş sedanın gücü: Müzikoterapi. SD dergisi. 2012(22):68-71. Go to source

  2. A Short Note About the Reconsideration of the Image of Bayezid II Darüşşifa

    Review · 2017

    A short note on the silhouette of the Bayezid II Darüşşifa in the Trakya University medical journal's logo. It notes that the hospital offered "experimental practices" such as music and occupation alongside the traditional medicine of the period, and that the building has presented this past as a medicine and health museum since 1997.

    A short note, not a peer-reviewed study; it gives no specific makam or time-of-day mapping.

    Kıranlar Ö, Koçak Z. A Short Note About the Reconsideration of the Image of Bayezid II Darüşşifa. Balkan Med J. 2017;34(3):187. doi:10.4274/balkanmedj.2017.3.0001 PMID 28559219 Go to source

  3. Makam

    Institutional page · 2003

    Entry "Makam": Safi al-Din al-Urmawi's Kitab al-Adwar describes twelve modes (uşşak, neva, buselik, rast, ırak, ısfahan, zirefkend, büzürg, zengule, rahevi, hüseyni, hicazi); in this system the twelve modes were matched to the twelve zodiac signs and the four branches to the four elements.

    The page gives 2003 as the print date.

    Özkan İH. Makam. TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi; 2003. Go to source

Linked to this claim

Method

Editorial responsibility
Murat Tunalı · Editorial responsibility lies with Murat Tunalı; no independent medical review has been carried out.
Sources and processing
Each citation was checked against its Crossref and PubMed record; fields that could not be found were left blank, and no figure or citation was guessed.
How this page was prepared
The first draft of the claim text was prepared by an AI model (Claude); citations were verified against primary records, and Murat Tunalı approved publication. Evidence methodology
Review
Last reviewed: 7 October 2026 · Next review: 3 April 2027
Updates
  1. Version 3 ·
  2. Version 2 ·
  3. Version 1 ·
Cite as
Frekans Studio. “A makam is a melodic system of Turkish music; its effect on mood is a historical account, not a scientific claim.”. Evidence library, version 3, last reviewed 7 October 2026. https://frekans.studio/en/evidence/makam-tradition

No cookies, no tracking. Details: Privacy notice (KVKK) On-device storage